Commercial leasing

Option to purchase and right of first refusal in a lease.

A right to buy the premises can be built into a lease, but an option to purchase and a right of first refusal are not the same thing, and the drafting decides what you really have. CMK Legal in Richmond advises tenants and landlords across Victoria on options to purchase and pre-emption rights.

Solicitor-reviewed

Option clauses reviewed by a Victorian property lawyer.

Fast turnaround

Advice back within 2 to 3 business days in most cases.

Fixed fee, quoted first

Fixed fee, quoted before we start.

Victorian leasing law

Grounded in Victorian property and leasing law.

The two kinds of right.

An option to purchase gives the tenant a right to buy the premises on set terms, which the tenant can exercise within the agreed period. A right of first refusal, or pre-emption, is only a contractual right to be offered the premises first, and gives the tenant no interest in the land.

The practical application of these clauses causes difficulty, because a right with no clear end point can leave a landlord unable to sell without constantly checking back with the tenant, so careful drafting matters.

Timing is read strictly, though equity may excuse a short delay, and an option to purchase is not protected by s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 in the way an option to renew can be.

An option to purchase and an option to renew are different rights with different protection. If buying the premises matters to you, the purchase right needs to be drafted and, where appropriate, protected in its own right.

Why the option clause matters.

You know what right you actually have

An option to purchase is a right to buy. A right of first refusal is only a right to be offered first. The two give very different certainty, and the clause decides which you hold.

The right is drafted to work

A poorly drafted pre-emption with no clear end point can be unworkable. Careful drafting makes the right enforceable without tying the premises up indefinitely.

Timing is handled strictly

Time limits on exercising an option are read strictly. Acting inside the window, and knowing where equity might help, keeps the right alive.

Protection is understood

An option to purchase is not protected as a tenant's interest in the same way an option to renew can be, so where it matters, the right is dealt with on its own terms.

Talk to us if.

  • You want a right to buy the premises built into the lease
  • You have been offered a first right of refusal
  • You want to exercise an option to purchase
  • A deadline to exercise the option is approaching
  • You are a landlord and a pre-emption is tying up a sale
  • You cannot tell if you have an option or only a first refusal
  • The premises are being sold and you hold a pre-emption right
  • You are buying a business with an option to purchase attached

Whether you hold an option to purchase or only a right of first refusal changes everything about your position. It is worth confirming which, and acting inside any time limit.

How we help.

  1. 01

    Send us the documents

    The lease, the option or pre-emption clause, and any notice or correspondence about a sale.

  2. 02

    Scope and fixed fee

    We scope the work and quote before starting.

  3. 03

    Review the right

    The clause is read to confirm what right it gives, its timing and whether it is enforceable.

  4. 04

    Talk it through

    We explain what you hold and how and when to act on it, by phone.

  5. 05

    Act if instructed

    If you want us to, we exercise the option, handle the purchase, or deal with the pre-emption on a sale.

Fixed fees for option advice.

Advice on an option to purchase or a right of first refusal is quoted as a fixed fee once we have seen the lease, with a call included. Acting on a purchase is quoted alongside the conveyancing before any cost moves.

Request a fixed-fee quote

FAQs

Option to purchase FAQs.

Still unsure? Call us on (03) 9008 7224 and speak to a lawyer, not a call centre.

What is the difference between an option to purchase and a first right of refusal?
An option to purchase lets the tenant buy on set terms by exercising the option. A right of first refusal only requires the landlord to offer the premises to the tenant first. The option gives far more certainty.
Does a right of first refusal give me an interest in the land?
Generally no. A right of first refusal is a contractual right, so it does not give the tenant an interest in the land the way an option to purchase can. That affects how it is protected and enforced.
What happens if I exercise the option late?
Time limits are read strictly, so a late exercise can be ineffective. Equity may excuse a short delay in some cases, but it is far safer to act well inside the window.
Is my option to purchase protected if the building is sold?
An option to purchase is not protected as a tenant's interest in the same way an option to renew can be. Where buying the premises matters, the right needs to be dealt with on its own terms.
I am a landlord and a first refusal is stopping a sale. What can I do?
A pre-emption with no clear end point can be difficult to work around. The answer depends on the wording, so it is worth advice on what the clause actually requires before you deal with a buyer.

Know your right to buy.

Start online or book a consultation with a CMK Legal property and leasing solicitor in Richmond, Melbourne.