Commercial leasing

Rent reviews in a commercial and retail lease.

The review method you agree to decides what the rent does for the life of the lease, and some methods only move one way. CMK Legal in Richmond advises tenants and landlords across Victoria on CPI, fixed and market reviews, ratchet clauses, and how to respond when a review notice arrives.

Solicitor-reviewed

Review clauses read by a Victorian commercial lawyer.

Fast turnaround

Advice back within 2 to 3 business days in most cases.

Fixed fee, quoted first

Fixed fee, quoted before we start.

Victorian leasing law

Grounded in the Retail Leases Act 2003 and VCAT practice.

How rent reviews work.

A rent review clause sets how and when the rent changes during the term. The common methods are a fixed percentage increase, a CPI adjustment, a market review, or a combination that applies different methods in different years.

Market reviews reset the rent to what the premises would command if offered to a new tenant and are usually the most contested, because they depend on a valuer's judgment and on the assumptions written into the clause.

For retail premises the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) regulates parts of the review process, including provisions that would prevent a market review from reducing the rent, so a clause that is effective in a non-retail lease may not hold in a retail one.

Reviews run to notice periods and deadlines. A right to question a market determination is often lost if it is not exercised within the window the lease allows, so a review notice is worth acting on promptly.

Why the review clause matters.

You see the real trajectory of the rent

A fixed increase compounds regardless of the market, CPI tracks inflation, and a market review can move either way. Knowing which applies in each year tells you where the rent is heading.

One-sided ratchets are brought to light

A ratchet stops the rent falling even where the market has dropped. For retail premises the Act restricts those provisions, so a ratchet that holds in one lease may not hold in another.

Deadlines are not missed

Reviews and the right to dispute them run to strict timeframes. Acting inside the window keeps your options open rather than leaving you bound by a figure you never tested.

A market determination can be tested

A market review depends on the valuer's assumptions and the words of the clause. Where a determination looks wrong, there is usually a process for challenging it.

The method you sign up to runs for the whole term.

The review mechanism decides what the rent does for the life of the lease, and the method chosen at the start is rarely revisited. Fixed percentage increases are predictable but compound regardless of market conditions. CPI reviews track inflation. Market reviews reset the rent to what the premises would command if offered to a new tenant, and tend to be the most contested because they depend on a valuer's judgment and on the assumptions written into the clause.

A common trap is the ratchet, a clause that stops the rent falling at a review even where the market has moved down. For retail premises the Act restricts provisions that would prevent a market review from reducing the rent, so a ratchet that is effective in a non-retail lease may not hold in a retail one. Timing matters as well. Reviews run to notice periods and deadlines, and a right to question a determination is often lost if it is not exercised within the window the lease allows. Reading the review clause closely before signing is far cheaper than arguing about its meaning once a notice has landed.

Talk to us if.

  • A market review notice has arrived
  • The lease has a ratchet that stops the rent falling
  • You cannot tell how the rent moves in each year of the term
  • A review date or dispute deadline is approaching
  • The rent has jumped and the basis is not clear
  • You are a landlord and want the review clause drafted to hold
  • A valuer's determination looks wrong to you
  • You are about to sign and the review method is unclear

The review clause is far cheaper to get right before signing than to argue about once a notice has landed. If you have already signed, we can still tell you how the next review should run.

How we help with a rent review.

  1. 01

    Send us the documents

    The lease, the review clause and any review notice or valuation in dispute.

  2. 02

    Scope and fixed fee

    We confirm whether the Retail Leases Act applies, scope the work and quote before starting.

  3. 03

    Review against the clause and the Act

    The mechanism is read against the lease and the legislation that governs reviews for your premises.

  4. 04

    Talk it through

    We explain what the clause does, what the notice means and the deadlines that apply, by phone.

  5. 05

    Act if instructed

    If you want us to, we respond to the notice or take the point to mediation or VCAT.

Fixed fees for rent review advice.

Advice on a review clause or a review notice is quoted as a fixed fee once we have seen the documents, with a call included. A contested market review is quoted separately before any cost moves.

Request a fixed-fee quote

FAQs

Rent review FAQs.

Still unsure? Call us on (03) 9008 7224 and speak to a lawyer, not a call centre.

What is a ratchet clause?
A ratchet prevents the rent from falling at a review, so it can only stay the same or rise. For retail premises the Act restricts provisions that would stop a market review reducing the rent, so a ratchet is not always effective.
Can my rent go down at a market review?
At a genuine market review the rent can in principle move either way. Whether a clause that blocks a reduction holds depends on the lease and, for retail premises, on the Act.
How is market rent decided?
Usually by a valuer applying the assumptions set out in the lease. Because those assumptions and the valuer's judgment drive the figure, the wording of the clause matters as much as the market.
When can I dispute a rent review?
Reviews run to deadlines, and the right to question a determination is often lost if it is not exercised in time. If a notice has arrived, it is worth getting advice quickly rather than letting the window close.
Which review method is best for me?
That depends on whether you are the tenant or the landlord and on your view of the market. The point is to understand what each method does across the term before you agree to it.

Get the review clause checked.

Start online or book a consultation with a CMK Legal commercial leasing solicitor in Richmond, Melbourne.