Commercial leasing

Repairs and maintenance obligations in a commercial lease.

The repair clause decides who pays when something in the premises fails, and the line between maintenance and replacement is where the argument sits. CMK Legal in Richmond advises tenants and landlords across Victoria on repair obligations, the landlord's retail duties, and disputes over plant that keeps breaking down.

Solicitor-reviewed

Repair clauses read by a Victorian commercial lawyer.

Fast turnaround

Advice back within 2 to 3 business days in most cases.

Fixed fee, quoted first

Fixed fee, quoted before we start.

Victorian leasing law

Grounded in the Retail Leases Act 2003 and VCAT practice.

Who is responsible for what.

A lease splits responsibility for the premises between the parties. A tenant is usually responsible for keeping the premises in repair and for day to day maintenance, while structural and capital items tend to stay with the landlord.

A widely drafted clause making the tenant responsible for all repairs can shift far more than a tenant expects, which is why the exact wording and the condition of the premises at the start both matter.

For retail premises the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) imposes a maintenance obligation on the landlord in relation to the structure, fixtures, plant and equipment it provides, and that obligation cannot simply be drafted away.

The condition of the premises at the start sets the benchmark for the term and for the make-good at the end, so a condition report taken before fit-out is worth having.

Why the repair clause matters.

You know what you are on the hook for

An all repairs clause can make a tenant responsible for far more than day to day upkeep. Reading it closely shows where the obligation actually ends.

The capital and maintenance line is drawn

Structural and capital items usually sit with the landlord. Separating those from maintenance decides who pays when expensive plant reaches the end of its life.

The landlord's retail duty is confirmed

For retail premises the Act makes the landlord responsible for maintaining the structure, fixtures, plant and equipment it provides. That duty cannot quietly be shifted to the tenant.

The starting condition is recorded

A condition report taken before fit-out sets the benchmark for repair and for make-good, and heads off the argument about what state the premises were in.

Maintenance or replacement, and who pays.

Repair clauses are where the line between maintenance and replacement is drawn, and that line decides who pays when something fails. A tenant is usually responsible for keeping the premises in repair and for day to day maintenance, while structural and capital items tend to stay with the landlord. A widely drafted clause making the tenant responsible for all repairs can shift far more than a tenant expects. The recurring example is an ageing air conditioning unit that keeps breaking down, where whether the eventual replacement is maintenance or a capital cost often turns on the precise wording.

The condition of the premises at the start sets the benchmark for the whole term and for the make-good at the end, which is why a condition report taken before fit-out is worth having. For retail premises the Act imposes a maintenance obligation on the landlord in relation to the structure, fixtures, plant and equipment it provides, and that obligation cannot simply be drafted away. What a tenant is actually on the hook for is a question of reading the repair, maintenance and make-good clauses together, rather than any one of them on its own.

Talk to us if.

  • The air conditioning or other plant keeps failing
  • The landlord says a replacement is your cost
  • The lease makes you responsible for all repairs
  • No condition report was taken before you moved in
  • You are a retail tenant and the premises are not being maintained
  • A repair dispute is affecting your ability to trade
  • You are a landlord and want repair obligations drafted clearly
  • The term is ending and repair feeds into a make-good claim

Repair, maintenance and make-good clauses work together. Reading them as a set, against the Act where it applies, is what shows who really pays.

How we help with a repair issue.

  1. 01

    Send us the documents

    The lease, any condition report, and the correspondence about the repair in question.

  2. 02

    Scope and fixed fee

    We confirm whether the Retail Leases Act applies, scope the work and quote before starting.

  3. 03

    Review the obligations

    The repair, maintenance and make-good clauses are read together, against the Act where it applies.

  4. 04

    Talk it through

    We explain who is responsible and how to put the position to the other side, by phone.

  5. 05

    Act if instructed

    If you want us to, we raise the issue with the landlord or tenant, or take it to mediation or VCAT.

Fixed fees for repair and maintenance advice.

Advice on repair obligations is quoted as a fixed fee once we have seen the lease, with a call included. A contested repair or maintenance claim is quoted separately before any cost moves.

Request a fixed-fee quote

FAQs

Repairs and maintenance FAQs.

Still unsure? Call us on (03) 9008 7224 and speak to a lawyer, not a call centre.

Do I have to replace the air conditioning?
It depends on the lease and whether the premises are retail. Replacement of ageing plant is often a capital cost that sits with the landlord, but a broadly drafted repair clause can shift it. The wording and the retail position decide the answer.
What repairs is a retail landlord responsible for?
For retail premises the Act makes the landlord responsible for maintaining the structure, fixtures, plant and equipment it provides. That duty cannot simply be drafted away, though the precise line is still worth checking.
What is fair wear and tear?
It is the deterioration that happens through ordinary use over time, which a tenant is generally not required to make good. Where the line falls is a common source of argument, especially at the end of a term.
Who pays for capital works?
Capital and structural items usually remain with the landlord, while the tenant carries day to day maintenance. A clause making the tenant responsible for all repairs can blur that, which is why the wording matters.
Why does a condition report matter?
It records the state of the premises at the start, which sets the benchmark for both repair during the term and make-good at the end. Without one, the argument becomes your word against the landlord's.

Sort out who pays for repairs.

Start online or book a consultation with a CMK Legal commercial leasing solicitor in Richmond, Melbourne.