Commercial leasing

Quiet enjoyment and the tenant's right to possession.

Quiet enjoyment is close to the only positive right a lease gives a tenant, so it carries real weight when trade is being disrupted. CMK Legal in Richmond advises tenants and landlords across Victoria on the covenant for quiet enjoyment, when a landlord is liable, and when a breach is a defence to a possession claim.

Solicitor-reviewed

Quiet enjoyment issues handled by a Victorian commercial lawyer.

Fast turnaround

Advice back within 2 to 3 business days in most cases.

Fixed fee, quoted first

Fixed fee for the initial advice, quoted first.

Victorian leasing law

Grounded in the Property Law Act and VCAT practice.

What quiet enjoyment protects.

Quiet enjoyment is the tenant's right to possess and use the premises without interference from the landlord or those claiming through the landlord. It is created by a covenant, which is simply a promise given by the landlord.

A landlord who breaches it can be liable for the loss the tenant suffers, and a serious breach can give the tenant a defence to a claim for possession.

Traditionally a landlord was not responsible for interference by third parties, but that line has shifted, and landlords and shopping centres have been held liable where another tenant or the use of common areas disrupts a tenant's trade.

Where works, noise or access problems are hurting your business, whether the landlord is answerable depends on the covenant and on who is causing the interference. That is the first thing to pin down.

Why this right matters.

Your right to trade undisturbed is understood

Quiet enjoyment is the tenant's core right. Knowing what it covers tells you when disruption to your business is something you can act on.

Landlord answerability is pinned down

A landlord can be liable for breaching the covenant, and in some cases for interference by another tenant or in the common areas. Working out who is answerable is the first step.

A defence is identified where possession is threatened

A serious breach of quiet enjoyment can be a defence to a landlord's claim for possession. Where you are facing eviction, it is worth knowing if the landlord has performed.

Centre and neighbour interference is addressed

A shopping centre can be responsible where common areas are used in a way that interferes with your trade. That is often overlooked until it is raised.

The one right every tenant has, and its limits.

Quiet enjoyment is the tenant's right to possess and use the premises without interference from the landlord or those claiming through the landlord. It is created by a covenant, which is simply a promise, and it is close to the only positive right a lease gives the tenant, so it carries real weight. A landlord who breaches it can be liable for the loss the tenant suffers, and a serious breach can give the tenant a defence to a claim for possession.

Traditionally a landlord was not responsible for interference caused by third parties, but that line has shifted. Landlords have been held liable for disturbance caused by another tenant, and a shopping centre can be responsible where the way common areas are used interferes with a tenant's trade. Where works, noise or access problems are disrupting your business, whether the landlord is answerable turns on the covenant and on who is causing the interference, which is the first thing to pin down.

Talk to us if.

  • Building works or noise are disrupting your trade
  • Access to the premises is being interfered with
  • Another tenant or centre activity is affecting your business
  • The landlord has entered without proper grounds
  • You are facing a possession claim and the landlord has not performed
  • A centre is not managing its common areas
  • You are a landlord facing a quiet enjoyment claim
  • You are considering withholding rent over a disruption

Withholding rent or walking out in response to a disruption carries its own risk. It is worth advice on the covenant before you take a step that could itself be a breach.

How we help.

  1. 01

    Send us the documents

    The lease and details of the interference, including dates, works and any correspondence.

  2. 02

    Scope and fixed fee

    We scope the initial advice and quote before starting.

  3. 03

    Review the covenant

    The quiet enjoyment covenant and the source of the interference are read against the lease and the Act.

  4. 04

    Talk it through

    We explain whether the landlord is answerable and how to put the claim, by phone.

  5. 05

    Act if instructed

    If you want us to, we raise the claim with the landlord, or take it to mediation or VCAT.

Fees for quiet enjoyment matters.

Initial advice on a quiet enjoyment issue is quoted as a fixed fee once we have seen the lease, with a call included. A contested claim at mediation or VCAT is quoted separately before any cost moves.

Request a fixed-fee quote

FAQs

Quiet enjoyment FAQs.

Still unsure? Call us on (03) 9008 7224 and speak to a lawyer, not a call centre.

What is the covenant for quiet enjoyment?
It is the landlord's promise that the tenant can possess and use the premises without interference from the landlord or those claiming through the landlord. It is close to the only positive right a lease gives the tenant.
Can I claim if the landlord disrupts my business?
A landlord who breaches the covenant can be liable for the loss the tenant suffers. Whether a particular disruption is a breach depends on the facts and the lease, so it is worth assessing before you act.
Is the landlord liable for another tenant's interference?
Traditionally not, but that has shifted. Landlords and shopping centres have been held liable where another tenant or the use of common areas interferes with a tenant's trade. Who is answerable depends on the circumstances.
Can I withhold rent if quiet enjoyment is breached?
Withholding rent is risky and can itself be a breach. A breach of quiet enjoyment may give you other remedies, so it is worth advice before you stop paying.
Is a breach a defence to eviction?
A serious breach of quiet enjoyment by the landlord can be a defence to a claim for possession. If you are facing eviction, whether the landlord has performed its side is worth checking.

Protect your right to trade.

Start online or book a consultation with a CMK Legal commercial leasing solicitor in Richmond, Melbourne.